Connect with us

Featured

Christmas Music 0 to 2013: A Word to the Wise

At one time, for a rather long period of time, most Christmas music consisted first of music that was liturgical. Although the earliest known Christmas music to become somewhat widely sung predates the 13th Century, when St. Francis of Assisi is credited with “inventing” the Christmas Carol…

Published

on

At one time, for a rather long period of time, most Christmas music consisted first of music that was liturgical. Although the earliest known Christmas music to become somewhat widely sung predates the 13th Century, when St. Francis of Assisi is credited with “inventing” the Christmas Carol, based on the chants, litanies and hymns that were sung in Latin, it is possible that some of the poetry and psalms that existed in Biblical times was “sung” by prophetic and kingly figures—at least until the time of King David. However, by the time St. Francis of Assisi adapted hymns into the rather more popular carol form, a new form of celebrating the birth of The Christ spread far across the continent. Strictly speaking, it was the English who combined the hymn with the musicality and lyricism of the circle dance and the carol as we know it today was born. It was John Audelay, a Shropshire priest and poet who was credited with compiling 25 “Caroles de Cristemas” as they began to be included in the repertoire of the “wassailers,” later called “carolers” groups of singers who went from home to home or orchard to orchard heralding and singing to avid listeners. Thus the carol was separated from the hymn as spiritual is from profane. Naturally this revelry was frowned up on during the iron-fisted Reformation when much of what begun as “Catholic” was supressed and ultimately banned as too profane a practice for church-going faithful. This lasted well past the Commonwealth of England, when Oliver Cromwell ruled from his seat in London.

BachIt was not until the Restoration to the throne in 1660 of Charles II, the Stuart Monarch that the practice of singing carols was restored to the church’s celebrations and therefore became legal in England and its realm again. But Christmas music as is known today did not become popular until the 19th century in England, again, as William Sandys’ Christmas Carols Ancient and Modern appeared in 1833, followed almost fifty years later by singing them in the church on Christmas Eve, 1880, with Nine Lessons and Carols sung in the Truro Cathedral in Cornwall. However, the creation of music to celebrate the birth of The Christ was marked by the composition of some of the most enduring music of all time, such as Thomas Tallis’ Latin MassPuer natis est nobis in 1554, Marc-Antoine Charpentier’s Pastorale sur la naissance de n.s. Jésus Christ around 1670. Then there is the cantatas and other music composed by Johann Sebastian Bach for Christmas to Epiphany and the Christmas Oratorio of 1734; probably the most famous today is Georg Frederic Handel’s Messiah which was composed in 1941, but actually premiered in Dublin actually in April of 1742; but which has become one of the most celebrated Christmas music since then. Hector Berlioz composed L’enfance du Christ between 1853 and 1854. Other well-known compositions are Camille Saint-Saens Oratorio de Noël (1858), Benjamin Britten’s A Ceremony of Carols (1942) and a slew of other Christmas cantatas from the Baroque to the modern (21st Century) era.

…Jump-cut to 2008/09, then fade to 2011/12

David FosterAnd no historic recollection may be complete without mention of He is Christmas (1991) by the a capella group Take 6, a miraculous sextet that uses advanced harmonies and truly sophisticated improvisations, while keeping the message in the forefront, and David Foster’s record, The Christmas Album (1993, then Universal Music Group, 2008). The sheer arrogance of using the definite article in the name of the record, suggests that Mr. Foster was pretty sure of what he was doing musically and his version of “Carol of The Bells” proves his point. His recording is all brilliant from there on. Of course there is the predictable appearance by superstars such as Celine Dion, who performs a truly magnificent version of “The Christmas Song”. But Mr. Foster also includes exquisite arrangements by Peabo Bryson and Roberta Flack (“The Christmas Song”) “O Holy Night” with Michael Crawford and a slew of other wonderful songs with a slew of fine artists. It is no wonder then how Mr. Foster’s record has become a classic five years on. One of Mr. Foster’s greatest assets—apart from his ingenious musicality, of course—is his ability to spot great artistry in others, then write enduring arrangements—he shares the arrangements on this project with two great arrangers, Jeremy Lubbock and the great Johnny Mandel. On this album, these wonderful arrangements blur the lines between musical idioms and bring artists together to sing and play his arrangements. What is also true is that Mr. Foster can make a small ensemble sound like a 100-plus strong orchestra. However, on this album, he is supported by a 75-piece orchestra. However, much of the music calls for vocalists to be present and what a stellar cast Mr. Foster assembles. Perhaps one of the finest charts on the album is “Blue Christmas,” which features a timeless-sounding vocal by Wynonna Judd. BeBe and CeCe Winans’ version of “The First Noel” has been cast on a spectacular musical canvas as is Johnny Mathis’ version of “It’s The Most Wonderful Time of the Year”. Another inspired arrangement is the medley of spirituals “Go Tell It On The Mountain/Mary Had a Baby” as is its protagonist, the wonderful Vanessa Williams. The vocalist does not appear too often in this role, but when she does she always turns in the most majestic of all performances. Perhaps there is something to be said of being picky. This record is what Duke Ellington would surely have called the sound of surprise.

Alexis Cole - The Greatest GiftAlexis Cole’s 2009 recording The Greatest Gift—Songs of the Season is another one of those spectacular recordings that never seems tired, no matter how many times it is played and listened to. This recording is just as spectacular as David Foster’s, but while Mr. Foster’s recording references several musical idioms, Ms. Cole’s leans completely towards the jazz and rhythm and blues idiom. Borrowing from the African idioms may be completely appropriate, as is seen and heard in the 2011 recording (later) made by Geri Allen. Although this narrows things down a bit, the sophistication of the music—which sometimes includes the Alan Farber nonet—is sometimes so blinding that it leaves the listener quite breathless. The African American Spiritual “Rise Up Shepherd and Follow” is superbly arranged. The inclusion of the Indian tabla and the tanpura, together with the soprano saxophone give the chart a truly ethereal air and make this version unlike anything that has been written and performed by any artist ever since modern recording can be tracked. Doubtless, there will be carols sung in the Indian vernacular that incorporate more ethnic idioms, but one that crosses the borders between Africa, Indian and the Americas would be hard to find. Ms. Cole’s vocal gymnastics throughout this chart are also quite special. Among the other special performances on the recording are those by the saxophonist, Don Braden, violinist Christian Howes, whose unbridled genius lights up each of the charts on which he plays, Alan Farber, who continues to remind listeners what a fine trombonist he is. The band’s choral version of “Silent Night” with spectacular dissonances appears late in the album and is well worth waiting for.

Bing CrosbyNew compositions are few and far between, but some performances of Christmas music are likely to endure almost endlessly. Perhaps as famous as anything created and sung for Christmas is the song, “White Christmas” by Bing Crosby. Although the fame of the song ought to be divided between Irving Berlin, its composer, and Bing Crosby, who made it famous, not once—as he did in 1942 when he first sang it on the radio; then several times until it became a hit when Mr. Crosby acted in and sung the now legendary song in the 1954 film, A White Christmas. Perhaps the bestselling song of all time, “White Christmas” the single has reportedly sold over 50 million copies worldwide. The chart has been covered by everyone from Elvis Presley (1954) and Al Jarreau (2008) to Andrea Bocelli (2009); Cee Lo Green (2011) to Rod Stewart (2012) and Erasure (1013). Yet Bing Crosby’s classic version remains the most popular ever. This and several other favourites appeared on a compilation album, Bing Crosby Christmas Favourites (2011) produced by Kathryn Crosby for the Bing Crosby imprint. It features 18 classic songs by arguably one of the most illustrious tenors in musical history. One of the 2011 albums that did not include “White Christmas,” and yet was one of the best Holiday album that year will continue to be This Christmas (BJR Records) by the Vancouver-based trumpeter and flugelhorn player Chris Davis. As a horn player, Mr. Davis uses all his wiles and brings many magical moments to his recording, which is informed by a warm, burnished tone and an extraordinarily colourful palette of sounds. Perhaps the highlight of this recording is its exquisite version of another Christmas classic “Little Drummer Boy” a 1941 composition from the pen of an American composer Katherine Kennicott Davis.

Geri AllenHowever, one of the most exquisite recordings of 2011 was A Child Is Born (Motéma) by the inimitable pianist Geri Allen. This spectacular recording was made largely as a solo pianist, but also included the voices of Connaitre Miller, Carolyn Brewer and Barbara Roney. The album begins with a monumental version of “Angels We Have Heard on High” a largely improvised essay featuring some wondrous counterpoint played by a powerful left hand by Ms. Allen. The surprise of the album is Thad Jones’ immortal composition “A Child is Born”. There is the suggestion that came from that other wonderful pianist, Marian McPartland that the chart ought to become a part of the Christmas canon. It took the unbridled ingenuity of Ms. Allen to make it so. However it may be two versions of “O Come, O Come Emmanuel,” which features the voices of the Quilters of Gee’s Bend that could be the showpiece of the album, not only for the short exquisite vocal interlude, but also for the majestic tone of Ms. Allen’s voice and her equally grand improvisations, both of which feature Ms. Allen’s extraordinary bass-line melodic and harmonic inventions. Geri Allen - A Child Is Born“Imagining Gena at Sunrise/Imagining Gena at Sunset” is one of those charts that is based on the apocryphal story of the Shepherds of Gena, who, it is believed visited the baby Jesus in his crib at the time of his birth. The song alludes to the game they were playing in Gena, Ethiopia before they made their journey. The haunting beauty of Geri Allen’s version “We Three Kings of Orient Are” and her stark improvisations in this chart make it one of the most mesmerising charts of all. Ms. Allen’s epic and seemingly endless inventions continue through “The Little Drummer Boy,” the two sets of Christmas medleys, “God is With Us” and “It Came Upon a Midnight Clear” until she returns to “O Come O Come Emmanuel” briefly, to close this magnificent recording. The packaging of this album was also one of its highlights and includes very beautifully written notes by the musician and educator, Reverend Dwight D. Andrews and lavish production by the label—all of which contributes to making this one of the most enduring of Christmas recordings in a very long time.

The year 2011 also saw the release of a superbly produced compilation Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas by the Montreal based label Justin Time. Executive produced by its owner Jim West, the album broke some rules and chose to mix traditional and modern versions of Christmas songs and carols. For instance, the spectacular pianist Oliver Jones’ superbly crafted and rather modern version of “It Came Upon a Midnight Clear” nestles rather comfortably with Hilary Cole’s “Let It Snow”. But then there is a rather madcap calypso medley of Christmas hymns which is all but forgettable thanks to “Little Drummer Boy” a masterful version by the New Jersey-born pianist Taurey Butler and his trio, followed by a swinging version of “Jingle Bells” by the celebrated Diana Krall; this priceless version swinging its way from stride, through swing and bebop before returning to its stride version. As if that were not enough, Ms. Krall is followed by Hank Jones’ majestic version of “The Christmas Song”, who is followed by Oliver Jones accompanying the wonderful contralto, Ranee Lee singing an almost aria-like version of “A Christmas Day”. But the most evocatively beautiful “Christmas Medley” by the Rob McConnell Tentet, one of Canada’s most celebrated big bands for several years, is the scene stealer on this compilation, despite the presence of Hank Jones, Oliver Jones and Diana Krall’s contributions.

Michael Buble - ChristmasPerhaps the most well-known Christmas recording is one that features a vocal artist who is very possibly the best-known by many accounts, since Frank Sinatra. On Michael Bublé Christmas Mr. Bublé shows why he was honored with a Grammy and nominated for another in the 2013/14 issue of the event. Although the Grammys is no exclusive indicator of the quality of music that an artist produces, it is eventually a fact that only the best of the best win. Also nothing is predictable about Mr. Bublé’s work. He continues to surprise with his vocalastics and his work on this album is no exception. Although most of the fare is wonderfully traditional in its selection, Mr. Bublé is one of the finest tenors and it bears mention that he seems to sound as wonderfully original as a certain Mr. Sinatra did in his heyday. While it may seem somewhat premature to compare Michael Bublé to Frank Sinatra, he is not really that far off and on his day he can phrase as marvellously as Ole Blue Eyes himself. Moreover Mr. Bublé is able to dazzle an audience like few other artists performing today and usually holds his audiences in the palm of his hands no matter where he is performing. Almost predictably, however, the finest song on this recording is “White Christmas”.

Halie LorenAnother fine Christmas recording—this one also from Justin Time, Montreal—was released in 2012. This one is focussed on the singular vocal styling of the Canadian Halie Loren, who is accompanied by Matt Treder on piano for this spectacular recording Many Times Many Ways. Ms. Loren is a graceful singer with an earthy and ethereal tone and manner. Perhaps being brought up in a place so far north—so close to the North Pole that is—gives the vocalist a dreamy, almost spectral manner. Her intonation is glorious, almost aglow. Ms. Loren’s enunciates her words with spectacular clarity and her lines always end with a fading vibrato that is almost ghostly in its beauty. Her version of “The Christmas Song” returns the song to its fable-like antecedents. “Winter Wonderland” is almost embarrassingly beautiful and proves that Mr. Treder is a pianist with greater than mere listening skills. Among his finer moments is the deliciously served up “Sugar Cookies” and suddenly it appears that Ms. Loren may not be the only star of the recording. But of course she is at least one half of it. One rather striking feature of her music is that despite her rather young years Ms. Loren handles more sensuous fare such as “Blue Holiday” and “Santa Baby” with extraordinary poise and a sensuous charm of her own. However, the highlight of her Christmas collection may easily be the hauntingly beautiful “Nature Boy,” a song not generally associated with the Season, but one which Ms. Loren almost magically makes so. And then there was this: a rather surprising offering from the Brasilian born Miguel de León, who served up not one but two CDs of music: one was music sung in his native Portuguese entitled Natal and the other was a recording of the same fare, but translated and sung in Spanish. This recording, predictably, was entitled Navidad. Both recordings are superbly produced and because Mr. De León is bilingual, his intonation and pronunciation in both languages are beyond reproach; in fact it is more like spectacular. Mr. de Leon has a velvety counter-tenor and is one of the most sophisticated voices to grace the music of Brasil. The arrangements of the Brasilian CD are rhythmically superb, although the translations of songs such as “The Little Drummer Boy” translated as “Meo Velho Tambor” might take some getting used to, when the music graduates from the foreign to the local things get a lot better. Charts such as “Boas Festas,” “O Ano Passando” and the marcha “Os Reis do Oriente” are exceptionally beautiful. And “Fim do Ano” which concludes the Brasilian segment of the album is quite the crowning glory of the album. Miguel de León’s Spanish language is just as beautiful. Much of this has to do with subtly changes arrangements and of course Mr. De León’s exquisite voice.

2013: The year of a man and a woman

Peggy DuquesnelThe year 2013 saw the rise of smaller labels and independents. Accordingly one of the most outstanding Christmas albums is most certainly the double album produced by pianist and vocalist Peggy Duquesnel. All I Ask for Christmas (Joy Spring Music) features a whole CD of instrumental versions of traditional Christmas carols and songs. But there are also four originals by the pianist, “All I Ask for Christmas,” “Christmas is Here” “Under The Christmas Tree” and the spiritually inclined “Light of Christmas”. Ms. Duquesnel is clearly an avid student of the history of jazz. She lets on right at the beginning of this recording as she launches into a magnificent vamp from “Blue in Green” to introduce an utterly beautiful version of “Little Drummer Boy” and continues harmonising her version of the song with that Bill Evans chart after Brian Bromberg, the bassist on the date plays an exceptional solo. Her Africanised version of “O Come O Come Emmanuel” is another spectacular chart—this one being rhythmically inclined naturally features percussion colourist Brian Kilgore and the inimitable Joe LaBarbera on drums. That Ms. Duquesnel is a fine pianist goes without saying. Her soli are exceptionally controlled and elegant and superbly crafted as if she were creating a great baroque edifice. But she can also be almost humbly simple in her approach to invention, which often—as in “Mary Did You Know”—makes for beauty that is stark and almost naked in its approach to pianistic invention. The African-Cuban version of “O Christmas Tree” is almost too delicious to enjoy. Once again, percussionists also excel in this chart. It feels almost appropriate that “Silent Night” should be a waltz with a slightly country flavour and here Jay Leech’s slide guitar played just under the vibes of Brian Kilgore adds just that subtle country touch to an already rocking waltz.

Peggy Duquesnel - All I Ask For ChristmasMs. Duquesnel’s version of “What Child is This” written in the almost identical quintuple (5/4) time that Paul Desmond wrote the classic “Take Five” But that is where the similarity ends? Not quite, as Joe La Barbera’s solo almost follows Joe Morello’s solo note for note in an extraordinary tribute to one of the most famous and inventive quartets in the history of jazz. On the vocal side of the business Ms. Duquesnel adds some sugar and spice to music that she has already performed as instrumentals, on CD1. This comes in the form of her delightful voice now added to her fine pianism as well. The fact that Ms. Duquesnel is an accomplished pianist has much to do with the beautiful performances on CD 1. Now she adds her vocals to this and the effect is quite amazing. Who knew that there would be a performer who would give Diana Krall and Patricia Barber a run for their money? Using the same ensemble as she does on her instrumental music, Ms. Duquesnel exceeds herself as do the other musicians. “Light of Christmas” and “Christmas is Here” besides some fine renditions of traditional Christmas music are among the stand-out charts on this vocal CD2. “All I Ask For Christmas” becomes a svelte duet here with Ms. Duquesnel and Bill Cantos. Elsewhere the vocals are complemented by Emma Werderman, a fine vocalist in her own right. Ms. Duquesnel performs some of the instrumental fare in their vocal incarnations, but a majority of the songs are exclusive to the vocal side of the offering, which also makes this package well worth the money, and is likely to remain so, this year and for several more to come.

Jonathan ButlerAnother splendid Christmas recording Merry Christmas To You (Mack Avenue) comes from Jonathan Butler, a vocalist with a natural and a singular style, and a range from counter-tenor all the way up to falsetto—a remarkable ability for an R&B singer today. Mr. Butler is also a fine instrumentalist and like Stevie Wonder, can play almost any instrument quite competently. His Christmas musical offering also reaches high point quite early in the proceedings as he starts his set with Donny Hathaway’s extraordinary song “This Christmas,” and his version of this chart could also melt the ice off the Polar extremities. It might also come as a surprise to many that Mr. Butler was born in South Africa, where he suffered much as an artist and triumphed when his first single was also the first by a black artist to hit the South African charts and be awarded the South African version of the Grammys. In the light of his background, his version of “Little Drummer Boy” is easily the classic of this recording, played at a haunting tempo, swung in inimitable style; it begins with a superb tribal-like call that melts into a gospel version of the classic song, before returning to end in a subtle choral setting, but with a rhythmic beating of the cajón and an udu drum as well. His “I’ll Be Home for Christmas” is a beautifully enunciated chart played tantalisingly slowly and with a fine, plaintive vocal. Mr. Butler also performs a frighteningly beautiful version of “The First Noel,” accompanying himself on guitar, an instrument he plays with exceptional passion, grace and fire. “O Holy Night” is another magnificently performed chart, where Mr. Butler puts his voice and his guitar through their paces and gives stellar performances on both instruments.

With such erudite performances as those by Ms. Peggy Duquesnel and Jonathan Butler, it might easily be suggested that both these recordings will endure as did David Foster’s and Alexis Cole’s did. The same might be said of Geri Allen’s recording, which is clearly one that stands apart from the rest of the recordings which feature similar fare in terms of traditional music performed almost too close to the traditional arrangements to be considered unique. Thus there may be many more recordings of Christmas, but when considered along with perhaps a cantata or the choral works of “The Messiah” their ingenuity and timeless quality is sometimes called into question. But not Bing Crosby’s 1942 version of “White Christmas,” or Geri Allen’s “A Child is Born”. Only time will tell.

Based in Milton, Ontario, Canada, Raul is a poet, musician and an accomplished critic whose profound analysis is reinforced by his deep understanding of music, technically as well as historically.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Featured

Sharon Isbin: A Small Orchestra on Gossamer Wings

Published

on

Sharon Isbin: A Small Orchestra on Gossamer Wings
Sharon Isbin photographed by J. Henry Fair

The guitar’s ancestors include the gittern, the vihuela, the four-course Renaissance guitar, and of course the baroque guitar, all of which contributed to the development of the modern six-string instrument. Few people in our day have mastered it with such alacrity, with such sage nobility and with such openness to the world of music around us as Sharon Isbin.

I admit to stealing the metaphor of the “small orchestra” from none other from Segovia. As a matter of fact, how ironic that one should have found it while listening to Miss Isbin’s recording of Karen LeFrak’s new works on the album entitled Romántico [Karen LeFrak Recordings, 2025]. Ironic because it is one that Miss Isbin undertook with the Orchestra of St. Luke’s conducted by Enrico Lopez-Yanez.

Cover design for Romántico [Credits as above]

Segovia’s stunning metaphor for the guitar also holds equally true of Miss Isbin performer and his characterisation of her musicianship would be spot on for his actual words are “The guitar is as small orchestra. It is polyphonic. Every string is a distinct colour, a different voice.”

Indeed, Miss Isbin exploits this characteristic to its fullest in such a seductive manner that she makes this aspect of her playing a truly alluring aspect of her own virtuosity, on this particular album as well as on her other discs, which is even more challenging as we shall soon as we go a little more in depth into the recording of Ms LeFrak’s works.

Exhilarating, extrovert and virtuosic
Romántico
features a world premiere recording of Ms LeFrak’s seductive Miami Concerto for Guitar and Orchestra. There is every indication that the composer had her heart set on making this record with Miss Isbin. She [the composer] has a deep understanding of the South American – Latin and Brasilian – music and selected her performers with punctilious care. It isn’t surprising that Miss Isbin would be a first choice.

Miss Isbin, in turn returns the favour. Her playing throughout the concerto is exhilarating, extrovert and virtuosic as so it should be. She is, after all, immersed in the realm of the Habanera and the Tango – music and dance forms that came to South America via the erstwhile colonisers from Europe. A deeper dive into the origins of the music lead unequivocally to the melodic, harmonic and rhythmic influences from the African continent.

Sharon Isbin photographed by J. Henry Fair

The guitarist is joined, here, by the Orchestra of St. Luke’s conducted by Enrico Lopez-Yañez. Ms LeFrak’s Miami Concerto for Guitar & Orchestra pays homage to oceanic musical heritage of Miami with influences from Africa, Europe and Latin America. “Bailamos,” the first movement of the concerto draws on the guaguancó, a dialect of the Cuban rumba, followed by a tango-inspired “Romántico,” and concludes with an energetic “Festivo” in the rhythm of bembé.

The chamber works “Habanera Nights” and “Urban Tango” feature Miss Isbin with Latin percussionists led by Javier Diaz, pianist Peggy Kampmeier, and New York Philharmonic principal cellist Carter Brey. Throughout the concerto and the chamber works Miss Isbin shows immaculate poise and thoughtfulness. She cultivates a beautiful, poetic tone with an orchestral touch offering a unique palette of colour amid riveting, charges interpretation of Ms LeFrak’s music.

Miss Issbin has delicate phrasing, a colourful touch and well thought-through ideas. Her performance is often a white hot volcano of intense expression; it presents formidable challenges, all of which are surmounted with almost insolent virtuosity, the guitarist’s focus resolutely serving the score, not the mechanisms supporting it. Miss Isbin plays with a particularly rewarding sense of rhythm, high sprung, light and incisive and entirely secure, which pays its way throughout all of the works.

But hearing her navigate through the massive cadenzas – de rigeuer on in these works – as if they and their beckoning grandeur were the most natural thing in the world leaves no doubt that this is an artist of the most elite order, to be watched intently, listened to deeply and reckoned with for an exceptionally long time to come. These are qualities of a guitar playing musician who is cast in the same mould as Segovia and the rest of the renowned artists of the instrument.

Cover design of Sharon Isbin: Affinity

Luminous tone , natural grace and authority
It is hard to put into word why this recording is so special. Perhaps the principal reason is that one of the finest guitarists has committed to disc, great works that she appears to have ostensibly lived with honing and polishing their subtle romanticism for a considerable length of time. Each movement and chamber work reveals her thoughtful artistry, exemplified by this slim volume. The five varied, but emotionally and [sort of] thematically interrelated pieces have been played with her hallmark luminous tone, natural grace and authority.

From this exquisite recording of Ms LeFrak to works by Leo Brouwer, Tan Dun, and Richard Danielpour, on which the web of charm has been spun by Isabel Leonard’s vocals] to a waltz by Antonio Lauro [in duet with guitarist Colin Davin] – and even a poetic cycle of love be Chris Brubeck which became the title of the recording, Affinity [Zoho Music, 2020] – this American guitarist proves herself to be one of the most versatile musicians playing on stage [and in the studio] today.

Cover photograph and design Sharon Isbin: Strings for Peace

This story is even more telling – and enduringly epic – because it catches something more of Miss Isbin’s genius in an incredibly unique way. Anyone who has listened to the range of her recorded performances, on her next two albums – Strings for Peace [Zoho Music, 2020] and Live In Aspen [Zoho Music, 2024] – will discover what it means for Miss Isbin to have a sense of daring and supreme confidence in her innate sense of sublime taste.

The former recording is made up of four North Indian Ragas, once again, all world premieres. Miss Isbin invites the grand sarod master Ustad Amjad Ali Khan on the apogee of the album [“Raga Pilu” alternatively entitled “Romancing Earth”]. Hi son Ameen Ali Bangash appears on “Raga Behag” or “By the Moon” while the performance of the other two ragas, “Raga Mishra Bhairav” or “Love Avalanche” and on “Raga Yaman” or Sacred Evening” are shared with the other son of the maestro, Ayaan Ali Bangash. The renowned tabla player, Amit Kavthekar, appears on all the four ragas.

We are speaking here of Miss Isbin having collaborated with musicians from the upper echelons of Hindustani music. But when it comes to a guitar being heard along with a sarod the first test is a mechanical one. There are obvious differences [between the classical guitar and the sarod] have to do with the fact that the instruments differ in pitch, and the dynamic and dramatic variance in their tonal and colour palettes. Add to that is the fact that both instruments are played pizzicato. This means that that it isn’t only the engineer who must have enormous ears.

Cover photograph and design for Sharon Isbin: Live in Aspen

Orchestral Gymnasium of the Guitar
The encounters between Miss Isbin and the Ustads of the sarod is quite breathtaking. And it is also here – on their studio and live recordings – that the extent of the technical mastery of each on their respective instruments is superbly demonstrated. The playing by the Ustads provides what in orchestral terms would be a shadowy kind of ground bass simply because of the tonal palette of the sarod makes this possible. And it is this effect that affords the guitarist an empty canvas on which to paint her masterpiece.

It is here that Miss Isbin exploits her guitar’s huge vocabulary of sounds and effects combinable to make it sound as big as an ensemble – but which need the player’s [in this excellent case, Miss Isbin’s] to deploy effectively. The evening ragas – Behag’s emotive aspects are daunting ass it is associated with times between 9 o’clock pm and midnight, Yaman is more crepuscular, its emotive aspects being associated with times between 6 and 9 o’clock pm, while Mishra Pilu us usually associated with between the afternoon and early evening.

On both Strings for Peace and Live in Aspen, Miss Isbin’s use of her wonderful instrument is truly eloquent and masterful. Her playing ranges from harmonics and pizzicato to technique exotica such as ‘nut-side,’ ‘nail sizzle’ and/or ‘bi-tone tapping’ [plus she also uses – even extends the battery of percussion possibilities, even entering into polyphonic and polyrhythmic dialogues with the tabla player Pandit Amit Kavthekar.

This spectacular array of harmonic pizzicato playing is also evident on Affinity where the need for the various composers to collaborate closely with Miss Isbin on each of their pieces. It’s complex for the composers to write not only for the instrument, but also for Miss Isbin. But neither of the parties are fazed. Miss Isbin is utterly amazing in this respect, as she has managed through inspiration and sheer persistence t0o wrinkle out from the composers a whole raft of adventurous works, almost independent of the ‘Sergovia tradition,’ but well within the elastic classical continuum.

Instrument as Orchestra – Miss Isbin’s Evolving Palimpsest
While this manipulation of the instrument is available to all masters of it, the players don’t strike pure gold as often as Miss Isbin does. Does she ‘get this’ from Heitor Villa-Lobos? One is willing to hazard a guess as it was the Brasilian composer who first started to treat the guitar as something bigger than it was supposed to be – and he was phenomenally successful as a composer to strike gold with regard to visualising and scoring for the instrument as a small orchestra.

For her part, Miss Isbin dwells constantly in that realm off possibility, continuing to extend the range and scope of the instrument with delicate albeit nervy fingers on gossamer strings. The sensuously liquid and always beckoning performance on LeFrak’s masterful works on Romántico are a cut above almost anything a guitarist has brought to life – this year at any rate.

As with her Bach – as spectacular and as mathematically and emotively as Bach intended his music to be – so also is her foray into Hindustani music [cue Strings for Peace], and contemporary classical music [cue Affinity]. Thus, having carved out a space for herself, non pareil, in the realm where composers have created a legacy for her to explore, she comes across with flying colours. One has only to dive deeply into her work on Affinity and into her Latin-American repertory.

The lyrical – often bittersweet – expressiveness that is intended by both the composers and the culture in which their music was written has enabled Miss Isbin to re-create wonderful soundworlds so big that in doing so she has embraced the richness that her instrument afforded her and [continues to] constantly work at recreating her musical palimpsest as if to say: “I hereby wish that my guitar should not simply respond to a full orchestra, but to become the full orchestra itself.

Continue Reading

Featured

Beth Levin: Heiligenstadt… En route to The Divine.

Published

on

Beth Levin: Heiligenstadt… En route to The Divine.
The pianist Beth Levin photographed by Gary Chapman

In many respects these last two recordings by Beth Levin – Hammerklavier Live and Phantasmata – may share an allusion to the famous Heiligenstadt Testament, albeit they represent the work of five different composers. Of course, the fabled Testament belongs to no one but Ludwig van Beethoven. Fabled…? Picture Beethoven as a kind of forerunner of our all-but-mythical Superman, one arm outstretched as he is about to pierce the mystical skin of the music of the skies en route to the Divine. Now picture all of the composers whose works Ms Levin has performed on these two recordings – a proverbial posse of legendary composer-meteors streaking heavenward en route to… the Divine

Indeed, Ms Levin has sojourned with them, practicing all her life as if to superscribe her career path onto that Heiligenstadt Testament. It is as if she were doing what Beethoven is believed to have exhorted every artist to do: “Don’t only practice your art,” he said, “But force your way into its secrets; art deserves that, for it and knowledge can raise man to the Divine.” And here we have two versions of that Testament representing Ms Levin’s quest to traverse the musical continuum streaking her way – and seemingly uniting it – via disparate parts of the world – through a space-time warp all her own. In doing so, Ms Levin has joined several imaginary dots in the sonic constellation of that heavenly continuum.

Ms Levin is the epitomé of a proverbial, questing artist rooted in the future, often looking back, then forward zig-zagging across the artistic firmament creating astronomical sonic connections that all come together in the end, uniting us – indeed raising us together with herself – to that Zion-like peak of her pianism… to the véritable apogee at the very heart of her musicianship. The beauty of it all is that one is unable to pronounce one better than the other. Rather they ought to be seen a Promethean musical expedition [without the heroic falls to the bas of the mountain of course] en route to its peak. And what incredibly good fortune to be part of this musical journey.

The main event of the 2020 recording – a live performance beautifully captured on record by Alan Wonneberger, at the Linehan Concert Hall, University of Maryland during the 2019 edition of Festival Baltimore – is, of course, Beethoven’s mighty Piano Sonata No 29 in B-flat major, Op. 106 ‘Hammerklavier’. On the way to the pinnacle of this recording Ms Levin joins some dots. From Beethoven’s great predecessor, Georg Frideric Handel. Her choice of the repertoire to draw a gossamer-like line from Handel to Beethoven is extremely interesting too, with a piece from a series that recalls his mastery of the keyboard – something his later German acolyte shared with him.

Functional, outstanding cover design for Beth Levin: Hammerklavier Live

This is Third Suite for Piano in D minor [from 8 Suites de Pieces Clavicin HWV 428. Characteristically this glorious suite also casts Handel in the role of the magnificent successor to J.S. Bach – not only as a keyboardist but also as a composer of enormous wit and invention. This is certainly true of the last movement of the suite – its Air with 5 Variations. Of course, the build up to this grand finale is magnificent to. Handel’s suites lend themselves to being played on the piano as well as on the Baroque keyboard.

Certainly, Ms Levin plays the entire suite eloquently. And so, when the playing is this good – as it is with the piano-caressing fingers of Ms Levin – it’s hard to imagine anyone playing them better than her. She brings a quality to this music which is both mellow and incisive. Above all, her playing emphasizes the brilliance of the music rather than the brilliance of her own playing. This too is portentous as Ms Levin swerves through her space-time continuum towards Beethoven’s ‘Hammerklavier’ via a 21st century piece – Anders Eliasson’s pianistically ingenious carousel. The detour is almost providential as it augurs well for the main event. The big ECG-like consonances and dissonances, its liquid glissandos and broad arpeggios take us to quite another world – as if reflected in a shattered mirror, in a forest, like a Mendelssohnian scherzo. All of which leads up to Ms Levin’s Beethoven.

The pianist’s technically astonishing performance should take its rightful place among the great performances of the epic sonata – with Pollini’s performance of Beethoven’s Late Sonatas. But, more especially to the point, Ms Levin’s ‘Hammerklavier’ is evocative of that most definitive performance by Solomon. And yet Ms Levin’s [performance is unsurpassable in its delicacy – especially in the brilliant Largo – Allegro risoluto movement.

Moreover, where the ‘Hammerklavier’ demands it she ensures that it gets the full powerhouse treatment – both at the beginning and at the end. This is surely how the composer must have imagined the music – both in terms that recall his Heiligenstadt Testament as well as in terms of the way the music is conceived – as being profound and intense in that quintessentially grand Beethovenian manner.

Cover, featuring Habima Fuch’s fabulous illustration, for Beth Levin: Phantasmata

She follows that seminal recording up with another brilliant one – this time with concept both similar – yet vastly different – to the live performance. This recording – like the title of the album itself – is [also] purposeful wandering through ‘a garden of delights’ reminiscent of a work by the great Argentinean writer Jorge Luis Borges. Thus, and indeed appropriately, the album is entitled Phantasma. Here we are beckoned by the pianist like that fabled mesmeric piper of Hamelin – through the Pictures at an Exhibition by Modest Mussorgsky.

This time, the grand lead in – even before the seductive Promenade – is via an exposition of another big work by arguably the greatest pianist of his [and many-an-era then or now] Franz Liszt, whose monumental work, the Sonata in B minor it is that leads us from one great hall in the museum of the sky into another great hall housing the Pictures at an Exhibition with which Mussorgsky paid homage to his friend – the architect and painter Victor Hartmann who died in 1873.

We are gently ushered – at times de rigueur commandeered – by the prodigiously-gifted pianist to Mussorgsky via the grand architecture of Liszt’s Sonata in B minor. It too has a homage – this one to Robert Schumann and is cast, like Schumann’s Fantasie in C, in three movements that are played without a pause. And it’s most appropriately played – as befits the vast work that it is – underlaid by a series of themes and motifs that grow, fuse and eventually expire. Three of the main motifs are stated in the opening bars: a softly ominous descending phrase, a wildly animated one, and a low growl of repeated notes.

Liszt weaves these together and drives these along a whirl of furious semi-quavers, exploring a kaleidoscopic range of thematic transformations. The first motif is escalated into a ‘big tune’ of grandiose dimensions; another becomes a lyric melodic line of great tenderness. The second movement ushers in a mood of subdued, even spiritual solemnity. Finally, although there is no tangible evidence indicating a representation of Goethe’s Faust, its difficult not to project a Faustian subtext, especially as Liszt does projects a demonic fury onto its last movement.

Many pianists treat the Sonata in B minor either as a barnstorming melodrama or as a rather unwieldly successor to Beethoven’s late sonatas. In Beth Levin’s hands the music’s visionary dimension stands out, but it feels as if every phrase has been carefully thought out in terms of weight and colour; the work’s undoubted histrionic quality is tempered by moments of iridescent delicacy and calm.

Beth Levin’s fingers caress the piano in Berlin. Photograph by Anna Chapman.

Again, the high drama if the Liszt sonata is a perfect build-up to second ‘main’ event – Mussorgsky’s Pictures at an Exhibition. Ms Levin leads us through the great hall of paintings, leading us in with the ubiquitous Promenade – the recurring theme representing “the viewer’s” walking between the Romantic and often fantastical pictures. There are ten pictures in all, each one a superbly atmospheric miniature that utilises the piano’s expressive potential in a way that suggests the influence of Liszt but reveals greater psychological insight.

A wide range of moods is depicted, from the sinister melancholy of – and mimicking the kind of dramatic short-legged walking tempi – of the Gnomus, through the playfulness of Les Tuileries [appearing to presage Claude Debussy], to the grand triumphalism of The Great Gate of Kiev. Although this is an epic suite for the piano it is almost always recalled in its version orchestrated by Maurice Ravel in 1922, and – in more recent times – by the rock version which the keyboardist Keith Emerson of Emerson, Lake and Palmer played on his great bank of electronic synthesizers [including a giant Moog].

Beth Levin gives us perhaps the most authentically grand version, a strong reading of the original piano suite, with bold and dramatic playing that makes one think that the orchestration didn’t  really add anything substantial to the work. In sheer colour and variety [cue Promenade], in the depth of its characterisation and the exceptional range and refinement of its pianism, Ms Levin imparts a power and dramatic stature to the ambience of this suite which no amount of orchestral bigness can – or has – achieved.

With buoyant, aristocratic grace and psychological ambiguity, Ms Levin brings an almost insolent virtuosity and swagger to the piano works on both recordings. This is the world of piano evoked as few practitioners could even hope to try and emulate.

Deo Gratis…

Beth Levin: Hammerklavier Live 
Music – 1. Georg Friedrich Handel – Third Suite for Piano in D minor [from 8 Suites de Pieces Clavicin HWV 428, first collection, 1720] – i. Praelüdium. Presto, ii. Allegro, iii. Allemande, iv. Courante, v. Air with 5 Variations, vi. Presto. 2. Anders Eliasson – vii. Carosello [Designo No. 3 for piano, 2005]. Ludwig van Beethoven – Piano Sonata No 29 in B-flat major, Op. 106 ‘Hammerklavier’ viii. Allegro, ix. Scherzo. Assai vivace, x. Adagio sostenuto. Appassionato e con molto sentimento, xi. Largo – Allegro risoluto [1817 – 1818].

Musician – Beth Levin: piano

Released: 2020
Label: Aldilá Records ARCD011
[aldilarecords.de]
Runtime: 1:12:21

Beth Levin: Phantasmata 
Music – Franz Liszt: i. Sonata in B minor [1853]. Modest Mussorgsky – Bilder einer Ausstellung [1874] – ii. Promenade, iii. Bydlo, iv. Promenade, v. Il veccio castelo, vi. Promenade, vii. Tuileries [Despute d’enfants apres jeux], viii. Bydlo [Heavy ox-cart], ix. Promenade. x. Ballet of the Unhatched chicks in their Eggs, xi. Samuel Goldenberg & Schmuyle, xii. Promenade, xiii. Limoges. Le Marche, xvi. Catacombae [Sepulchurm Romanum], xv. Cum Mortuis in lingua mortua, xvi. Baba Yaga. The Hut on Fowl’s Legs, xvii. The Great Gate of Kiev.

Musician – Beth Levin: piano

Released: 2024
Label: Aldilá Records ARCD024
[aldilarecords.de]
Runtime: 1:12:08

Continue Reading

Featured

Orli Shaham Serves Champagne, Fizz and Finesse with her Mozart: The Complete Piano Sonatas

Published

on

Orli Shaham - Mozart: The Complete Mozart Piano Sonatas
In Orli Shaham's hands Mozart's sonatas are evoked as few would even dare to try.

The days when pianist and pedagogue Orli Shaham “played” the proverbial younger sibling to her more famous brother, the celebrated violinist Gil Shaham are over. With her monumental box-set Mozart – The Complete Piano Sonatas now in the rearview mirror, it’s also time to survey a Mozartian road, somewhat well-travelled. Admittedly, ‘comparisons are – quite literally – odious’ albeit Ms Shaham’s Mozart sits high atop – if not at the very top – of a list of 10 superlative compendia such as this Mozart one; certainly, Mozart – The Complete Sonatas and Variations [EMI, 2000] by Daniel Barenboim comes to mind, and, of course, Glenn Gould’s…

But, Mr Barenboim’s set includes three discs containing the Variations, which leaves Gould’s by virtue of it being similar in scope to Ms Shaham’s. One comparison does beg mention for more than one reason, apart from the fact that both sets are a sort parallel-road-travelled. Both Ms Shaham and Mr Gould are prodigious pianists who penetrate the wonderful world of Mozart’s genius. Both are highly acclaimed pedagogues – Mr Gould [courtesy of two epic recordings of The Goldberg Variations [Columbia/Sony, 1955 and 1981] – more highly regarded as an interpreter of Johann Sebastian Bach, and both are [were, in the case of Mr Gould] successful broadcasters.

Orli Shaham photographed by Aleksandr Karjaka

There is, however, one major caveat: matters inevitably and unalterably sunk Mr Gould [after he aired his views on Mozart]. His first self-inflicted wound came on April 28th, 1968, when he produced a two-part radio broadcast, which was aired on PBS. The broadcast was entitled How Mozart Became a Bad Composer in Mr Gould went as far as to disparage the ingenious composer as a better writer of the inter-office memo than a composer. He was referring to Mozart’s late work – one sonata, to be precise – and although some have made light of the comment the pianist-turned-‘opinionated broadcaster’ was unlikely to have been joking.

The programme was never re-broadcast, and the comment remained hidden – and forgotten – until the New-York-based documentary filmmaker Laura Carra unearthed it forty-eight years later. Many [especially those from the Glenn Gould Foundation] had glossed over the comment referring to the programme and the Mozart comment as a revelation of “the comic side of his persona on television.” I’m not so sure. Moreover, Mr Gould was referring to Mozart’s Sonata No. 13 in B-flat Major, K. 333, otherwise known as The  “Linz” Sonata.

Mr Gould had a reputation for being a naysayer. Remember his famous public ‘quarrel’ with Leonard Bernstein over the interpretation of Johannes Brahms‘ First Piano Concerto at a New York Philharmonic concert on April 6, 1962? At any rate he may have inadvertently shot himself in the foot again when he released Mozart: The Complete Piano Sonatas, Volumes I and II [Columbia Masterworks, 1979]. There were, of course, no liner noted disparaging comments this time. He just played that fine sonata quite superbly. And it certainly was no inter-office memo…

Orli Shaham’s Mozart: The Complete Piano Sonatas is now available in a box-set

Back to Ms Shaham’s Mozart: The Complete Piano Sonatas, which is certainly more beckoning than Mr Gould’s – more, that is, in the masterly realm of the interpretations recorded by Mr Barenboim…

The quality of her playing throughout her epic survey of Mozart’s sonatas. Ms Shaham takes nothing for granted in these works – indeed, in music as a whole. Nor should we in listening to her. If you know how your Mozart goes, certainly in his eternal penchant for lyricism goes, or his genius for the greater harmonic ingenuity and melodic richness displayed in his later sonatas, for that matter. Which is not to say that she does anything wildly idiosyncratic, let alone provocatively iconoclastic, a la Glenn Gould. At the same time, she digs deeper into each miniature, the very minutiae of everyday life, so to speak – especially Mozart’s relationship to each character and story evoked therein.

Nor does the pianist, blessed with prodigious musicianship, show any signs of being a budding [Mozartian] prophet. Rather, she plainly understands that every interpretation is just one possibility, and she offers us a very enticing opportunity to open our minds, especially in familiar works burdened by tradition – in this case the interpretations which, in the wrong hands, have tended to sound uninteresting, even formulaic. Perhaps this is what Mr Gould ought to have looked at rather Mozart’s playful and quick-witted compositional approach, both of which Ms Shaham brings out in masterly fashion.

Her delicate phrasing creates a feeling of innocent melodiousness, yet each movement is intelligently worked out, and her subtle manipulation of timing conveys a keen sense of that playfulness and quick-witted character that Mozart always exudes. In each case, across the grandeur of the 6-discc set, Ms Shaham’s reading are fresh and spacious – and in the case of Sonata No. 11, the A-major, “Alla turca” K. 331 [disc 3], Ms Shaham shows off Mozart’s true genius not simply for the form, but his puckish sense of surprise right from the first movement onwards.

It begins, not with the customary fast movement but with a gentle, almost folk-song like lullaby which goes through a series of sprightly, if conventional variations. The ensuing Minuet and Trio leads without a break into the infectiously animated Rondo “Alla turca” – a whirling dance which, like the fifth violin concerto, reflects the fashion for all things all  things Turkish. And then there is the Sonata No. 14 in C-minor K. 457 [disc 6], written in 1784, which could hardly be more different than anything he’d written hitherto.

This is Mozart’s  grandest solo work: terse, pithy and inward-looking in a way that seems to anticipate Beethoven. [Seven moths after completing it, Mozart wrote an introduction to the sonata in the form of a Fantasia. The sonata – with or without it – remains a studious and intense work, with a startling range of moods, and in Ms Shaham’s delicate hands it provides a most vivid portrait of Mozart the brilliant keyboard player.

In a quote from the liner notes Ms Shaham tells us: “It was the one sonata of the eighteen I needed to think about more… {I was] eager to put all of the emotional content out there to be judged. I’m all about vulnerability,” she concluded. All of this shows immediately. Ms Shaham takes us into another world. It is a world full of glinting lights, mysterious depths, expectations, frustrations, doubts and hopes, like a late-quasi Mozartian scherzo, glimpsed by moonlight in a forest.

Even if she recorded nothing but the No 14, Ms Shaham’s genius for Mozart would have been reflected through her interpretation of this sonata alone. In sheer colour and variety, in the depth of characterisation and the exceptional range and refinement of its pianism, Ms Shaham here imparts a power and stature to this sonata, which no amount of ‘bigness’ [the usual route taken by pianists] can achieve. Her delicate lyrical, and intent to ‘let it all hang out’ is perfectly suited to the work.

In conclusion one might add the following observation after surveying each of the sonatas as they were releases on one or two discs at a time, over a period of time, [and now as a comely box-set]: Ms Shaham brings out all of these sonatas myriad delights… always with a degree of grit beneath the filigree surface, perhaps, yet overall they are everything you expect from both the genius who is Mozart as well as everything that the definition of a sonata was meant to be: To hark back to the works of Arcangelo Corelli and his contemporaries, a form first described by Sébastien de Brossard in his Dictionaire de musique [Amsterdam, ca. 1710]? literally, a piece played as opposed to a cantata [in Latin cantare, ‘to sing’]; a piece sung.

In these Mozart sonatas are indeed – to coin a new compound epithet that describes them perfectly both sonate-cantare. Orli Shaham brings effortless Mozartian urbanity and lyricism to all  the items, which are as seductive as they are persuasive, an object lesson in the very essence of style. Each is played with buoyant, aristocratic grace and psychological ambiguity. And she is [rightly] almost insolently effortless in bringing debonnaire virtuosity, even sassy swagger to each of the pieces. A fitting tribute to the icon who is Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. All in all, a dazzling world of Mozartian sonatas evoked as few would even dare to try.

Continue Reading

Most Read Since 2011